Cold War Spies and Intelligence: Comprehensive Fact Check
Generally Credible
19 verified, 0 misleading, 0 false, 0 unverifiable out of 19 claims analyzed
The transcript presents a richly detailed historical narrative of Cold War espionage activities, focusing on the Allied Military Liaison Missions, prominent spies, and significant intelligence events from 1945 through the 1980s. Most claims within the transcript are corroborated by declassified documents, historical accounts, and academic research. The account accurately describes key espionage cases such as Klaus Fuchs, the Rosenbergs, George Blake, Oleg Penkowski, and spy swaps at the Glienicke Bridge. It also provides credible descriptions of covert reconnaissance efforts, surveillance techniques, and the dynamics between Western and Eastern intelligence services. Minor details about motivations or subjective interpretations are consistent with scholarly analysis. Overall, the transcript is highly credible and provides a trustworthy insight into Cold War intelligence operations and their geopolitical ramifications.
Claims Analysis
The Allied Military Liaison Missions in Germany had close access to Soviet military equipment during the Cold War.
Historical records confirm the Allied Military Liaison Missions enjoyed unique diplomatic privileges allowing close reconnaissance within Soviet-occupied East Germany, often inspecting Soviet military hardware firsthand.
The missions operated under an agreement established in 1944 and implemented in 1945 between the Allied Powers.
The missions originated out of post-WWII agreements among the US, UK, France, and USSR to liaise in occupied Germany, which evolved later into intelligence operations as Cold War tensions increased.
Soviet sentries near mission areas were known to be trigger-happy, sometimes shooting first without warning.
Incidents such as the 1985 shooting of Major Arthur Nicholson by a Soviet sentry are documented examples of the risks Allied officers faced, indicating strict and sometimes violent Soviet enforcement of restricted areas.
Klaus Fuchs was a German physicist and member of the Communist Party who spied for the USSR within the Manhattan Project and was sentenced to 14 years in prison in Britain.
Public historical consensus confirms Fuchs' espionage activities and his 1950 conviction in the UK, where his sentence was lighter than others due to the USSR being an ally during WWII.
Julius and Ethel Rosenberg were executed in 1953 for passing nuclear secrets to the USSR, with controversy about Ethel's minor involvement.
The Rosenberg trial and execution are well documented, with debates among historians about the extent of Ethel’s role, but their conviction for espionage is established.
George Blake was an MI6 officer who spied for the KGB, escaping prison in 1966 and living in Moscow thereafter.
Blake’s double agent activities and prison escape are well documented in intelligence histories.
The Berlin Tunnel was a joint British-American operation to tap Soviet communications, discovered in 1956 due to a KGB mole (Blake).
Operation Gold (the Berlin Tunnel) was a real joint operation compromised partly by Blake's betrayal, leading to its exposure by the Soviets.
Major Arthur Nicholson was killed in 1985 by a Soviet sentry near Ludwigslust while photographing a Soviet T-80 tank.
The incident is a documented Cold War casualty resulting from reconnaissance activities near restricted Soviet military zones.
The U-2 spy plane piloted by Francis Gary Powers was shot down over the USSR on May 1, 1960, resulting in his capture and imprisonment.
This is a well-known Cold War event widely recorded in historical sources.
Oleg Penkowski was a Soviet GRU colonel who spied for the West and provided critical intelligence on Soviet nuclear missile deployments prior to the Cuban Missile Crisis.
Penkowski’s espionage and importance during the Cuban Missile Crisis are acknowledged by historians.
The CIA’s Corona satellites launched in 1960 captured high-resolution images of the USSR, prompting widespread improvements in camouflage by Soviet forces.
Corona is considered the first successful photographic reconnaissance satellite program, influencing Cold War military strategy.
George Blake's KGB espionage included betrayal of the Berlin Tunnel operation, allowing it to continue to some extent despite initial compromise.
Blake’s double agent role is documented as allowing the Soviets to manage and mitigate damage from the tunnel’s tapping.
Between 1941 and the end of WWII, the USSR was an ally of Britain, influencing Klaus Fuchs’ sentencing.
The wartime alliance reduced the perceived severity of Fuchs' espionage compared with later Cold War traitors.
Walter Ulbricht publicly accused the Western military missions of espionage in East Germany and interpreted their activities as preparing for offensive war.
Ulbricht’s speeches and East German propaganda frequently condemned Western missions’ intelligence activities as hostile espionage.
Heinz Felfe was a KGB mole within the West German BND’s counterintelligence, exposing hundreds of agents and severely damaging the agency.
Felfe’s infiltration and compromise of the BND counterintelligence services is well documented in Cold War intelligence history.
John Anthony Walker betrayed US Navy communications codes to the USSR for nearly two decades, severely compromising US Navy operations.
Walker’s espionage is recognized as one of the most damaging in US history.
Ryszard Kukliński was a Polish general who spied for the CIA from 1972 to 1981, providing almost 350,000 documents on Warsaw Pact plans.
Kukliński’s defection and his provision of detailed Warsaw Pact intelligence are documented and well recognized.
The 'Able Archer' NATO exercise in 1983 nearly triggered a Soviet nuclear response due to Moscow's misunderstanding of NATO intentions, with double agent Oleg Gordievsky providing critical warnings.
Declassified documents and memoirs confirm the 'Able Archer' crisis as a major Cold War flashpoint, with Gordievsky’s espionage providing crucial insights.
Robert Hanssen and Aldrich Ames were KGB moles who betrayed numerous CIA sources and operations to the Soviets, leading to deaths of informants.
Both cases are among the most infamous American espionage betrayals, extensively documented by US agencies.
[narrator] Some just count tanks. [explosion] Others steal blueprints for nuclear bombs.
The Cold War is the battleground
for thousands of spies and spotters. [translation] Both sides collected
intelligence in order to avert what was considered
to be a looming war.
The secret services have few scruples
when it comes to procuring intelligence. They pay for acts of treason,
which may spell death for those exposed. Do I have an awareness of blood guilt?
No, I didn't.
They were spooks with a license to spy. The men of the Allied Military
Liaison Missions in Germany were at the forefront of the intelligence
war between East and West.
Yet even today, hardly anything is known
about their feats. [translation] No other western
intelligence service got as close to Soviet military equipment.
But where there are secrets,
there's danger, too. We knew that Soviet sentries
were trigger-happy. They tended to shoot first
and ask questions later... if at all.
Kalashnikov stuck in my neck. Okay, so you don't move, okay. The risks were... pretty enormous.
In fact, how on earth I am still alive, in fact, how any of us are still alive,
I have no idea. They were friends.
I understand what it takes
to lose a friend. A close friend. [narrator] It's a tour that brings back
memories to three Cold War veterans.
White gloves would have been reserved
for parades, since their targets were out in the field. Their job was military intelligence.
Their brief, covert observation. Lawrence G. Kelley, a former US Marine, Jean-Paul Staub of the French Army
and Nigel Dunkley
of the Royal Scots Dragoon Guards. They're browsing through dossiers
that were once top secret. We actually served
as a kind of carpet sweeper,
vacuuming up everything
that might be relevant, because we never knew until the end,
what was most important. The threat posed by Soviet military power
is precisely documented in the old files.
It's familiar stuff to Staub and Dunkley. Both men were tank experts. As only close-ups photographs would do,
they had to sneak up to their targets. A risky business. Shots from a film showing
the British Military Mission in action.
A tank crew has spotted the snoopers. A soldier is approaching fast
to apprehend them. It's only by a hair's breadth
that the Brits succeed in getting away.
[man] Steady forward. Sometimes they take even greater risks. Like when they were
inspecting the inside of a tank.
They climbed onto the tank, opened the hatch, and were stunned
to see that the crew was asleep inside! So, they very gingerly closed the hatch,
dismounted the tank
and made their getaway. The officers of the military missions
are out to get at the military secrets hidden deep inside the GDR,
the Soviet-controlled eastern part
of Germany. Their weapons:
cameras with special lenses. The missions had ben established
due to an agreement between
the Allied Powers of World War Two, the United States, Great Britain,
France and the Soviet Union. That was back in 1944.
Procedures were implemented
the following year, after Hitler and Germany
had been defeated. [translation] The intention had not been
to create an intelligence apparatus,
but to use the missions as relays between
the Supreme Commands in occupied Germany. The reason for the missions to
be established is absolutely obvious. Because we had four headquarters,
four commands in Germany.
They had to communicate, to liaise. There are countless issues to take care
of across the occupation zones. Provisioning the populace,
coping with millions of refugees,
tracking down war criminals
and the repatriation of POWs. [speaking German] [translation] So, the missions had
a semi-diplomatic, semi-military brief
with a view to getting the Allied
administration of the four zones working as well as possible. Yet with the advent of the Cold War,
the victors soon turn into adversaries. The missions begin using their status
to collect military intelligence. The Western Allies make forays
into in the former Soviet Zone,
now the GDR,
the German Democratic Republic, while their Russian counterparts
roam the newly founded Federal Republic. It‘s an explosive game,
part diplomacy, part espionage.
There are some restricted areas
which are off-limits. As for the rest,
it's "Thou shalt not be caught." Since their official duty is still
to liaise between the Occupation Powers,
the members of the missions
enjoy special privileges. They had the same status
as diplomatic couriers. Otherwise they had
complete diplomatic immunity.
You cannot search them,
you cannot detain them. So they could do many things and they had free travel possibilities
throughout the country.
So, Americans, Britons and Frenchmen, each accredited by the Supreme Command
of the Soviet Army, are entitled to regular forays
into East Germany.
The western missions
are based in Potsdam, near Berlin. 63 of their members are officially listed for the so-called "tours"
under diplomatic status.
The Soviets set up their respective camps in the former American, British and French
zones of occupation in Western Germany. Both sides soon make use
of their "diplomats in field dress"
to systematically spy on the other side. Their observations are a welcome addition
to the output of classical espionage. [jet engine roars]
[explosion] The most sensitive area during the early
years of the Cold War is nuclear research. At this stage, only the USA has
the capability of delivering an A-bomb.
Yet spies such as Klaus Fuchs... Julius and Ethel Rosenberg... or Rudolf Abel
are risking their lives enabling the USSR
to become a nuclear power. August 1945. Americans celebrate the victory over Japan
and the end of World War Two.
Three weeks later, a Soviet cypher clerk
in Canada switches sides. When they debrief him, western
counter-intelligence experts are alarmed. [cheering]
For the rest of his life, Igor Gusenko
will only appear in public heavily masked. The defector has good reason
to fear the revenge of the KGB, since he has alerted Washington
to the presence
of countless Soviet moles
in American institutions. [translation] Gusenko was a key figure
in a process which could be described as the discovery of the Soviet Union
as an aggressive,
expansionist dictatorship. His interrogation helped expose a network
within the Canadian, but most of all within
the US administration,
whose branches,
and I mean nearly all of them, were infiltrated by communists. The Gusenko file triggers
an all-out counter-spy offensive
against suspected communists
throughout the United States. The secrets of the nuclear program
are at stake, especially since American engineers
are testing ever more powerful bombs
over the Pacific Ocean. [explosion] Possession of the A-bomb is crucial
for the balance of power
during the Cold War. As long as the United States
is the sole nuclear power, its position is nearly unchallengeable.
From the American perspective, it's a state of affairs best kept that way
as long as possible. [Geiger counter clicking]
In 1950, the FBI exposes a spy-ring centered around
Julius and Ethel Rosenberg. The couple had passed secret information
about the American nuclear program
on to the Soviet Union. The Rosenbergs themselves
were comparatively small fry. Their prominence is mostly due to their
spectacular trial and its circumstances.
The prosecution succeeded in presenting
a star witness from inside the spy ring, Rosenberg's brother-in-law. To save his own skin, he testified,
and this of course meant that others
would take the rap. David Greenglass,
Julius Rosenberg's brother-in-law, had provided the secret documents.
Yet, there are other, more important,
nuclear spies working for Moscow. [explosion] In 1949, the Soviets successfully test
a nuclear device.
Without their American informers, they might have needed several years more
of their own research. Their most important source of information
is Klaus Fuchs,
an exiled German physicist
working for the Manhattan Project, America's nuclear program, and a member
of the German Communist Party since 1933. In 1949, by then in Britain,
he comes under suspicion.
He hands himself in and is sentenced
to 14 years in prison. The explanation for this
comparatively light sentence, far below the death penalty,
is quite simple.
Fuchs had committed treason, yes, but the beneficiary of his betrayal
had been an Allied power, since from 1941 until the end of the war,
the USSR had been fighting
on the side of Britain. An extenuating cause that is denied
to the Rosenbergs. They are executed for having spied for
the new arch-enemy of the United States.
The verdict on Mrs. Rosenberg
was a judicial crime. She should never
have been sentenced to death, since her involvement had been
a relatively minor one.
But the court was determined
to set an example. [archive reporter] Julius and Ethel
Rosenberg had paid their debt to society with their lives.
[narrator] Their execution is portrayed
as a fitting punishment for having betrayed the United States. 1985.
US military spotters on tour
in East Germany. keeping a low profile
while trying to catch a glimpse of the Soviets' brand-new
main battle tank.
Stalking a tank had its risks. Watching videos from the 80s, military mission veterans
Dunkley, Kelley and Staub
recall what it was like
to sneak up on their prey. [indistinct audio on video footage] A Soviet-built T-80. A prime catch.
[Dunkley] T-80 was... hot. T-80 was the brand-new tank. And it was the pride and joy
of the Soviets at the time.
And it was a pretty bad shock
for NATO to discover it was good. It was an outstanding tank. [Kelley] The fire control system
of the T-80 was very important as well.
Tank modernization in GSFG
was well underway, And this was a critical aspect of it. Major Arthur D. Nicholson
and his driver, Jessie Schatz,
are approaching a tank firing range
near Ludwigslust in north-east Germany. We knew that Soviet sentries
were trigger-happy. They tended to shoot first
and ask questions later... if at all.
Yet, Nicholson has set his mind
on the tanks' hangars... which are next to a restricted area. The two men scan the surroundings
for Soviet sentries.
Sometimes the area, the training area
I mean, was sensitive, and sometimes it wasn't. But we all knew that a sentry
was normally posted there.
Lawrence G. Kelley flew attack jets
with the Marines before he was posted to
the American Military Mission in Germany. By 1985, Kelley is second in command.
"Nick" Nicholson has become
a good friend of his. Kelley knows only too well
what happened that Sunday afternoon. LUDWIGSLUST
Four months earlier,
a tour of the French Military Mission had come under fire
near those very hangars. Nicholson isn't in the least deterred
by the accident.
Quite the contrary. Possibly that could have indicated that
something important really was there. And I am certain that Nicholson
considered that point.
Hardly recognizable under its tarpaulin,
a T-80. To a military spotter,
a first shot is like a trophy. The Soviets had begun to deploy
their most modern tank
in the southern parts of East Germany. By 1985, there are rumors
of its presence in the north. But there is no proof yet.
[distant gunfire] NATO's headquarters want just that, visual evidence.
Nicholson probably hopes to find it
right here near Ludwigslust. Nicholson and Schatz do not detect
any sentries around. But there is one...
a bit further off, in the bushes. Nicholson advances to reconnoiter
the area behind the hangars. Nicholson was proud, well-educated,
motivated and ambitious,
and in my opinion, he had an above
average affinity for risky actions. Whatever he may have seen there... he decides to retreat.
But the sentry had indeed seen the tour. And relatively early. And he reported that fact
to the Guard officer
over a system like a field telephone. "Missiya, Missiya," he said.
"A mission tour is in the area!" And the Guard officer asked,
"well, where is it now?"
And the sentry replied, "it's gone." To which the Guard officer answered,
"well... When it comes back, you know what to do."
Nicholson and Schatz do indeed return. But the sentry doesn't know how to proceed
in accordance with standing orders. And even if he does,
he doesn't adhere to the rules.
He watches on, as Nicholson gets out
of the car again. Then things get out of hand. -Come back!
-[gun shots]
Shots ring out.
Nicholson is hit by a bullet. The sentry holds Schatz at gunpoint,
keeping him from administering first aid. When a physician arrives an hour later,
Nicholson is already dead.
Schatz detected the sentry at essentially
the same instant as the first shot. And he ducked. The shot whizzed narrowly over his head.
Either the second or the third shot
hit Nicholson "center of mass," below the heart and somewhat inside
the rib cage. Sergei Savchenko
remembers the events well.
In March 1985, he is stationed
in Wünsdorf, the seat of the Soviet Supreme Command
in East Germany. He's an interpreter with the section
dealing with
the western military missions. When I came, I think it was
something like between 6 and 7 pm, to the headquarters, I did not
have any idea what was going on.
I could see that everybody was excited. While his superiors hasten to Ludwigslust, he handles any incoming news.
This way, Savchenko soon gets
first-hand knowledge of what has happened. When they came to Ludwigslust,
to the place itself, of course everybody was shocked.
Because... to see the body
lying almost next to the vehicle. And to see Jessie Schatz inside
and a group of Soviet officers around. Photographs that have long
been top secret.
It soon becomes obvious that procedures
have been gravely mishandled. And not only by the sentry. If you put a sentry with a weapon,
with ammunition anywhere,
according to the Russian regulations,
it has to be a post. And this post has to be clearly marked
on the ground or terrain. There has to be an fence
or barbed wire.
There were no signs. No fence.
There was no nothing. This sentry was nowhere to be seen. Jessie Schatz is kept in the car
for six hours.
That is how long it takes Lawrence Kelley
and his boss, Colonel Lajoie, to reach the site. Only to be confronted by Soviet officers
with allegations
that the Americans alone are responsible
for what has happened. The argumentation became incandescent, with extraordinarily sharp accusations,
and the tension mounted continuously. The Soviets initially demanded
to detain and interrogate Schatz, to seize and search the vehicle,
and to perform an autopsy
on Nicholson's body. The Americans reject the Soviet demands. They merely agree to a joint autopsy.
Nicholson's body was transported back
to a Soviet morgue in Potsdam in a Soviet ambulance, and I escorted it. Colonel Lajoie had given me the mission
of ensuring that Nicholson's body
was accorded the proper respect. It's a somber drive to Potsdam. Kelley is cowering inside the Soviet
ambulance next to his friend's body.
Underway, I looked at Nicholson
again and again, and mentally asking him each time, "Nick,
how could this possibly have happened?" The death of Major Nicholson
turns into a major incident.
His coffin is transported back
to the United States, observing full military honors. Nicholson is survived by his wife
and their only child.
The government pays its respects to him
as a fallen hero. [cameras click] Major Arthur Nicholson
was an outstanding officer,
murdered in the line of duty. We grieve with his wife
and small daughter. We can only hope that the Soviet Union
understands that this sort
of brutal international behavior jeopardizes directly the improvement
in relations which they profess to seek.
Our deep sympathy goes
to all his friends and relatives. May he rest in peace. Three years will pass
until the Soviet authorities
half-heartedly acknowledge
their responsibility for the shooting of an American officer
in peace time. I said to myself why can we not admit
that the soldier was not the best solider
in the Soviet army. And in fact he was not the best soldier
in the Soviet army. If we admit that then we can say
to the Americans
that we are sorry that it happened. But it happened
because we had a bad soldier and because we had
an inadequately organized post.
That's it. It will not affect
the relations between our countries. Because in any army,
you can find a bad soldier. Due to their briefs,
Savchenko and Kelley meet regularly.
As interpreters for their respective
top brass they even begin to appreciate each other. Yet for Lawrence Kelley the tragic death
of Nick Nicholson
still casts a long shadow. It is dramatic. And I understand the reason why
Larry Kelley...
speaks about all that with such...
passion. They were friends. And I understand what it takes
to lose a friend.
A close friend. Major Arthur Nicholson paid with his life for trying to photograph a Soviet tank.
The Allied Museum in Berlin. Lawrence Kelley, Jean-Paul Staub
and Nigel Dunkley stand in front of a display case
remembering Jessie Schatz.
The tragedy near Ludwigslust
affected him badly. Up until then, he was known as
an easy-going guy full of clever ideas. Like hawking so-called "Berlin Watches"
to tourists.
Larry Kelley still recalls the details. Schatz was a natural-born wheeler-dealer. He peddled trinkets of various kinds
in the mission
and at flea markets all over Berlin. Souvenirs mostly, sometimes watches. Problem was,
that his business, as he preformed it, was only marginally legal, if at all. And the command ultimately told him
to cease and desist.
Former Staff Sergeant Schatz
died in 1996 at the age of 42. A Candy-bomber. A reminder of the Berlin Airlift,
eleven dramatic months which marked the
beginning of the Cold War back in 1948. Intelligence about the intentions
and capabilities of the other side now becomes of paramount importance.
Thousands of agents and spies risk their lives to bring it home
to their masters. The airlift ensures the freedom
of more than two million people.
The Soviet stratagem
to strangle West Berlin has failed. Yet, as tension between the opposing
power blocks mounts, so too does the hunger
for secret information.
[speaking German] [translation] Both sides collected
intelligence in order to avert what was considered to be a looming war
and to achieve more safety
for their own side. That's why, apart from so-called
open sources, you'd want additional, secret information.
And that was the province
of the intelligence services and the military missions. Thus, Berlin becomes the hub
for military reconnaissance men,
secret agents and informers of all kinds. April 1953. Seven British subjects
return home from the Korean War. For almost three years
they had been held captive
by the Communist regime in the North. Among the returnees, here in the center,
is George Blake, an operative of MI6,
Britain's foreign intelligence service.
There may be no sign of it yet, but he has come back to work as a mole
for the KGB, Russia's secret service. Three years later.
In East Berlin, a 450-meter tunnel is triumphantly exposed
by the communist media. Americans and British had combined
to tap telephone cables
on the other side of the Iron Curtain. The Berlin Tunnel was an operation, whose sheer size was, and still is,
without precedent.
Planning included, it ran for more
than two and a half years, and it tied up enormous resources, in terms of money and personnel-wise,
both British and American.
Moscow accuses the West of a war-like act. The CIA and their counterparts at MI6
had driven the tunnel from west to east with utmost care.
Yet Blake blows the operation
long before the tunnel is finished. For the time being, however,
his masters let their opposite numbers carry on with their eavesdropping.
The output seems well worth the effort. 50,000 magnetic coils of telephone calls,
mostly between military stations. Even today, after many files
have been declassified,
the CIA still maintains
that they were able to retrieve a treasure trove
of information out of these more than 500,000
recorded phone calls.
Yet why does the KGB let this
continue for so long? Even if they managed to plant some amount
of disinformation on the eavesdroppers, there are still several hundred thousand
genuine phone calls
for their enemies to analyze. [speaking German] Soviet Intelligence had decided
to sacrifice their own military's secrets
to protect their source, George Blake. This is the most plausible explanation. For the KGB, it's a move that pays off.
Blake exposes countless MI6 operations,
even betraying agents in Eastern Europe, agents he himself has recruited. In 1961, the mole's cover is blown.
Blake is sentenced to 42 years in prison. In 1966, he pulls off
a spectacular escape. His escape is basically an extension
of his experiences in the war.
He had been a prisoner of war
in North Korea. He had had to survive
under the most adverse conditions. There was torture, all these things.
You don't know if you will
ever get out alive. But he had survived, and this had made him
feel that he could cope with anything. He never ceased to believe in himself.
To him, it was just another kind of war, and he wanted to win that war
for his own sake. And that meant escaping from jail.
Blake scales the prison wall
and escapes to Moscow. What had made him a traitor
in the first place? I wonder if Blake ever was
on the British side.
He was a Brit, of course, but in his autobiography,
he states right at the beginning that he was convinced that a world in
peace is only possible under Communism.
And that he wanted to contribute
to changing the world order in this direction. Blake uses his occasional appearances in
front of a camera to justify his actions.
That his acts cost former colleagues
their lives... this is not something
he's wanting to hear. North of Magdeburg.
A museum of Soviet trucks
and other military hardware. Nigel Dunkley, Jean-Paul Staub
and Lawrence G. Kelley close-up with their former objectives.
Among them, the redoubtable air-to-ground
missiles of the SA-6 series. [speaking French] [translation] It was the first time
that I had seen the SA-6 this close.
It was an extremely powerful
weapon system, and definitely one of the best of its era. On the grounds
of the former Soviet barracks,
the three Cold War veterans look on
with professional nostalgia as the curator unpacks
the once closely guarded components. Electronic modules
which set the frequencies
at which the missile received
its target data. [Dunkley] We would have been very happy
to bring back that to Berlin. Devices like these were of prime interest
to NATO experts.
To procure them was easier said than done. [Kelley] Analysts in various headquarters
always had wish lists and justifiable wish lists.
But they couldn't possibly know the risks
that we would have to run to make their wishes come true. Fulfilling some of them would have been
tantamount to suicide.
That's why the decision as to whether
the potential results were worth the risk was left to the men on the ground. But the expert's eye detects
some intriguing details
about the missiles' origin. I had my doubts because the color
of the equipment, the lighter green, was not usual for Soviet forces.
Soviet equipment produced
in the Soviet Union and used in Soviet forces
was normally darker. And indeed, apart from some labelling
in Cyrillic,
there is faded lettering in Polish. To Lawrence Kelley, it's clear evidence
that the missile originally belonged to a unit of the Polish Army.
His hunch was right. The Warsaw Pact armies'
air-to-ground arsenal ranked high with NATO reconnaissance.
Over Vietnam as well as
in the Middle East, Soviet-built missiles had proven
to be a deadly weapon. Electronic countermeasures may enhance
the pilots' chance of survival.
Their development, however, depends
on exact data on the set-up of a missile. At the close of the 1950s, the American's
U-2 is regarded as the ultimate spy-jet. Out of reach for any missile,
they fly over testing areas,
nuclear factories and military bases. Their pilots regularly venture into
Soviet airspace with a sense of impunity, photographing from
a height of 20 kilometers.
Until May 1st 1960. To Francis Gary Powers
it's just another mission. Yet this time, the Russians
have a surprise in store.
When the U-2 crosses the Urals, they
launch their latest anti-aircraft missile. [rattling] Powers is lucky to be able to eject
and to survive the descent
hanging on his parachute. To the Americans
it's a most embarrassing incident, forcing them to cancel all further
spy flights over Soviet territory.
On August 19th 1960, Powers is tried
for espionage by a military court. The Soviet authorities make full use
of the opportunity to brand the United States as warmongers.
Powers is sentenced
to ten years in prison. Three years later.
Another trial in Moscow. This time in the dock, Oleg Penkowski,
a high-ranking officer of the GRU,
the Soviet military intelligence service. He had switched sides and betrayed information
about Moscow's nuclear potential
which had been cause for deep-seated fears
in the West for more than a decade. [speaking German] [translation] Penkowski had access
to highly sensitive material,
but most notably about the development
of missiles and their intended deployment. To the Americans, this was, of course,
of the utmost importance. The cause of Penkowski's treason?
He had felt slighted by his superiors. Penkowski, by then a colonel,
was expecting his promotion to general. He had had a fine career,
but suddenly found himself at a dead end after a security check had revealed that his father had been a general
in the Tsar's army.
From then on, his promotions came to
an abrupt end. His career was more or less over, and that's what made him
break his allegiance to his country.
In 1960, Penkowski contacts the other side and delivers detailed insights
into Moscow's military arsenal. Types of missiles,
their range and numbers,
plus information
about the air defense system which blew the U-2 out of the sky. Penkowski also warns
of Soviet Premier Nikita Khrushchev's
aggressive nuclear policy. Two years later, U-2 planes
spot Soviet nuclear missiles in Cuba. American analysts identify them
as SS-4 and SS-5...
which can carry their warheads
as far as Chicago. Thanks to the information
supplied by Penkowski, the photo interpreters know exactly
what to look for,
since each type of missile
requires a distinct set-up. And this was the pattern that Penkowski
had passed on to the Americans. Once their experts had found it
on the aerial photographs,
they knew that this was a launch pad for
a specific type of medium range missile. US President John F. Kennedy
imposes a naval blockade around Cuba. Should these offensive
military preparations continue,
thus increasing the threat
to the hemisphere, further action will be justified. The world is on the brink
of a nuclear war.
Skillful diplomacy, and a good deal
of sheer luck, avert a nuclear apocalypse. Penkowski is arrested a few days prior
to the Cuban Missile Crisis, tried and sentenced to death as a traitor.
The impacts of his treason
are far-reaching. Both sides begin to build and deploy
intercontinental ballistic missiles. Back then, there is no chance
of intercepting them.
He who shoots first dies second. Yet, there are new, highly efficient tools
for reconnaissance and espionage. Satellites orbit the earth and capture
stunning high-resolution images.
In August 1960, the Americans launch
their Corona program. Its satellites can monitor the Soviet
Union without any interference from below. The capsules containing the exposed shots
still have to be ejected by the satellites
and picked up in mid-air. Both sides expend billions
on their respective programs. But the satellites prove to be superb
guardians against any surprise attack.
The quality of their photographs
improves rapidly. As a consequence, both sides try hard
to conceal their secrets by camouflage. And to catch a glimpse,
you need agents on the ground,
just like the officers of the military
missions in both parts of Germany. Each vehicle transporting
sensitive equipment was issued with cloaking devices.
Tarpaulins were a must. And a challenge for snoopers
who would pride themselves on being able to sniff out
what was underneath.
Tarpology was an art form. In order to become a master of tarpology you had to learn by heart
every single type of camouflage
used to cloak the other side's weaponry. We had to know what was underneath
the tarpaulin. And so we did. The Soviets had various ways and means
of camouflaging and disguising
their equipment it was all part of what they called
maskirovka, but they didn't fool us.
In the end, we could identify
virtually everything. Oh, yes! [laughs] We most certainly did. Even if they had to resort
to cutting holes in the tarpaulin.
Spy planes come in many guises. In the airspace around Berlin, the western missions use small aircraft
to peek down into Soviet army barracks
or to shadow their opponents'
field exercises. The air corridors to West Berlin, too,
are systematically used for covert reconnaissance, focusing on
military infrastructure on the ground.
There are three corridors,
each 32 kilometers wide. A fifth of Eastern Germany
can thus be photographed practically without any risk.
Yet there are incidents. The RB-66 is a highly specialized
reconnaissance plane. In 1964, one of them shows up in the
middle corridor heading for West Berlin.
US Airforce footage gives
a rare impression from inside the labs for high end espionage hardware
as it was installed in an RB-66 jet. There are cameras, antennae,
sophisticated radar, jamming devices, signal recorders. Yet the corridors aren't meant
to be spy lanes.
Any suspected bending of the rules
may lead to a dangerous encounter. [gunfire] In March 1964, Wolfgang Preisler
is working as a chauffeur
with the US mission when he gets the order to take a tour
officer to the crash site of an RB-66 near Gardelegen,
in the middle of a restricted area.
A tricky proposal. The likelihood of being able
to stay undetected was very slim. So, we knew that but we did get within
probably 100 yards,
100 meters of the, uh, crash site. Because we were able to see the embers. Preisler and his tour officer
are pondering how to best approach
the crash site proper, since, some distance off,
the area is crawling with soldiers. Then they notice something
quite unexpected.
The trees around them seem decorated
as if for Christmas. A bunch of silver confetti hanging off
the trees. And... which was a little odd.
And only shortly... five minutes after,
we picked off some of these pieces and looked at them and wondered, you know,
where they had come from. The RB-66 had probably released
the tinfoil as chaff
in an attempt to blind the Russian radar.
Alas, without success. It was only minutes thereafter that the
Russian soldiers came and blocked our car, from the front, from the back.
And they detained us
for about 12 hours. The three-man crew of the shot down
jet are released a few days later. They had survived
thanks to their parachutes.
One of them, however, is severely injured. The Americans deny any allegation that
this had been a reconnaissance flight. According to them the jet had strayed due
to a compass error unnoticed by the crew.
The Soviets are anything but convinced. Sergei Savchenko at the site
of his former duty station. In his role as an interpreter
with the staff
of the Soviet Supreme Command
in East Germany he had become quite familiar with the
routines of the western military missions. Basically we kept track of the activities
of the mission members.
Of their pranks, their exploits, their deeds, misbehavior. My room was number 13,
the boss's room was number 12.
In the corner
we had Mr. Lyudomirskiy. Colonel Lyudomirskiy office. And he was nicknamed "Colonel Schlagbaum."
Schlagbaum because his service
was responsible for the Glienicke Bridge passage. The checkpoint at Glienicke Bridge
is the gate through which
the western missions enter East Germany to proceed
to their assigned areas of operation. Every car is registered
by the authorities.
Whenever a mission tour passes the bridge, units of the East German State Security
are waiting for them. It's the start of a never-ending game
of cat and mouse
between the snoopers and their shadowers. On February 10th 1962, the bridge between East and West
makes international headlines.
A few minutes before 9 am two men are
led towards the middle of the crossing. On the one side, there is Gary Powers
of the notorious U-2 incident, at the other end is Rudolf Abel,
an illegal KGB resident
in the United States whose cover was blown in 1957. Ironically, neither side was sure that
the exchange really was a good deal.
The Americans were gravely concerned
whether Powers might at some point have disclosed vital information
to his Soviet captors. Their interrogation methods, to which
he surely would have been exposed,
were notorious. Doubts were also fueled
because he'd let himself be captured alive instead of taking the suicide pill
he had been provided with.
That was held against him, as well as the fact that he didn't trigger
the automatic self-destruct of his U-2. And so, he kind of fell into disgrace.
The suspicion that Powers
might have talked, however, is not confirmed by later research. At the time of his arrest,
Rudolf Abel is regarded
as the most important KGB operative
in the field of nuclear espionage. He avoids the death penalty,
but only just. His sentence, 40 years in prison,
may well have shown that he was more
useful to his captors alive in the event of a future spy exchange. His brief had been to sort of resurrect
a network of nuclear spies
from the wartime period and to work as an illegal resident
in the USA, behind enemy lines, so to speak.
That's what the KGB had trained him for and why they subsequently sent him
to America. Yet it's a gross misunderstanding
to see Abel as this "master spy."
During the nine years he resided
in the USA, he did not personally recruit
one single new agent. The Americans had been expecting
much more from him
in terms of information
than he could deliver. He just didn't know very much. So the famous exchange
on Glienicke Bridge
merely repatriated two men who, each in their own way,
had disappointed their masters. But the CIA, as well as the KGB,
had no choice.
Those who let their agents down
won't find any new recruits. The Bridge of Spies.
A symbol of the Cold War. Time and again, Nigel Dunkley,
Lawrence G. Kelley and Jean-Paul Staub
set out from here into East Germany. They belonged to a hardly known elite
of intelligence gatherers... who roamed enemy territory.
They don't think of themselves as spies. Their tours, they say,
had been perfectly legal, accredited by the Soviets.
Some covert observation, yes of course, but in a struggle for information,
it's the results that count. And, as they see it,
they managed to deliver.
We observed the Soviets,
up close and personal, as the saying goes, and knew the realities of their
Armed Forces better than anyone else. Our knowledge was practical,
not theoretical,
and we provided our authorities
with an unbiased, first-hand, boots on the ground assessment
of Soviet military capabilities. Which was very important
at the height of the Cold War.
Whether uniformed snooper
with a diplomatic passport or top agent under cover, the bridge at Glienicke has seen them all.
Intelligence gatherers on dangerous
missions across secret fronts. [narrator] East Germany in the 1980s. It's the deployment zone for 20,000 tanks.
[man speaking French] [translation] Another one, another one,
another one! Since an army's heavy equipment
is usually transported by rail,
military snoopers turn into trainspotters. Their brief: to count tanks
and to identify units. The men of the western military missions
like Lawrence G. Kelley,
Nigel Dunkley and Jean-Paul Staub
often lie in wait for days on end. The military missions had been established
to sort out problems between the occupying powers
in post-war Germany.
Their members enjoy the status
of diplomatic couriers, yet they soon use their privileges
to spy on their opponents. The Soviets are touring West Germany,
while Americans, French and Brits roam the territory of the
German Democratic Republic in the East. Their main objectives:
the other side's battle tanks.
A rail track north of Magdeburg. As the memories come back, Kelley, Dunkley and Staub decide to steer
their veteran off-roader
to the nearby town of Barleben. Once, this was a perfect spot for spies. [speaking French]
[translation] On some days, you could
easily watch half a dozen trains going by as an armored division was either leaving
for an exercise or returning. To western snoopers,
Barleben was a key location.
From here, the rail track leads directly
to Letzling Heath. Back then, this was the most important
training area for Soviet units in Eastern Germany.
Out of bounds
for western military missions. They could merely look on as the trains
entered the restricted area. Always under the eyes
of the State Security, or Stasi,
and the Vopo,
the notorious People's Police. Sometimes we only had perhaps 20 minutes, or perhaps 30 minutes at the most
before the Vopo would be along.
And, of course,
it was like a cat and mouse game. On most occasions, they get away. But not always.
A propaganda-video shot by
the State Security in 1978. [soldiers shouting] A team of American snoopers
is caught in the act.
A tarpaulin across the windshield
blinds the driver. A Soviet jeep cuts off the retreat
of the mission car. Its occupants surrender.
The license plate of their car
is recorded, and their spy-tools are displayed
for the camera. The missions are a nuisance
for the East German Government.
Walter Ulbricht, the chairman of the State
Council accuses them of espionage. [speaking German] [translation] Look here, this camera.
It's 92 centimeters long.
Not exactly an amateur device. To Ulbricht, it's evident. The missions are reconnoitering targets
for an offensive war.
At least that is his interpretation
of the maps they have seized. [translation] This merely confirms
that the representatives of the US mission were especially interested in the areas
of their envisaged military thrust.
No state enjoys being spied upon. Yet in this case,
there is no way to prevent it. [translation] The rules were based
on the joint jurisdiction
for all Allied Occupation Zones
in Germany. Therefore, Ulbricht had to accept
that East Germany couldn't act as a sovereign state
in these matters
and had no legal authority
to prohibit this kind of espionage. In 1960, espionage is but one problem
for the East German state. There is a virtual exodus
of its citizens towards the West.
The very existence of Communist Germany
is at stake. In 1961, its leaders decide to stop
the bloodletting by erecting a wall. They don't care about the human suffering
that will be caused
by the partition of Germany. The Western powers accept the wall
as unavoidable. [woman sobs]
[crowd cheers] In 1963, US president John F. Kennedy
visits West Berlin. Nine months before,
the Cuban Missile Crisis
had brought both sides to the brink of a nuclear confrontation. But the most perilous days
of the Cold War seem to be over.
-Ich bin ein Berliner.
-[crowd cheers] Kennedy pledges
to defend Europe's freedom.. with nuclear weapons if need be.
East and West alike
expand their strike potential. There is no defense against
intercontinental missiles launched from silos or submarines.
And if this were not enough, there are now several thousand
tactical nuclear warheads deployed in both parts of Germany.
[engine roars] Rod Saar, a Royal Air Force officer
with the British military mission, lies hidden in the dark
when a pair of headlights approach.
It's a jeep. It stops. [engine idles]
[engine stops] A Soviet soldier is checking
the barbed wire. The slightest noise may give Saar away.
Saar is waiting for Soviet fighter jets which are scheduled to appear
in a few hours for practice attacks with live ammunition.
He hopes to get
some revealing photographs. Back then, in the early seventies, Saar has a reputation
as a cool, calculating daredevil.
The challenge was really to get to these targets
without being interfered with by the Stasi or the Soviets,
in particular.
Uh, to be able to get in close. So those were the kind of challenges
you faced. But experience was an issue.
So it took time to gain confidence
and understanding of the terrain. Saar and his companion intend to hide
directly beneath the jets' lane of approach.
At daybreak, their cover must be perfect. Soviet firing ranges
and bombing practice areas are prime locations
for western military snoopers.
They are out to spot new types of planes
and their armaments, and to assess their strike potential. A Stasi guard has detected
unwelcome spectators from the West.
An interference Saar would rather avoid. You would sit under the flight line, because the Stasi would not come under
the flight line.
They didn't want to have bombs
dropped on their heads. So, they avoided that. So that was a kind of different strategy.
[chuckles]
[electrical crackling] Rod Saar, well camouflaged
under the approach lane. To him, as an Air Force man,
flight maneuvers are highly revealing.
In 1971, he is watching an SU-17, NATO codename "Fitter," when its pilot suddenly performs
a steep climb.
An unusual maneuver for dropping a bomb. What's behind it? [jet engine roars]
[explosion] Astonished, Saar continues
to observe the plane. So the aircraft flew in at 400 feet,
low level,
And then it goes into a steep climb,
up to 2000 to 3000 feet, and then towards the top of the climb,
it releases the bomb which actually then is thrown forward.
It then, in fact, in the end,
rolls out and flies off at high speed. So it was simulating
a tactical nuclear attack. And here actually is the simulated
nuclear weapon underneath the aircraft.
It was the first time
that we had seen that. And it indicated the capability for tactical nuclear strike
by the Soviets.
Even when the target practice is over, the range itself can be full
of interesting finds. Parts of projectiles may indicate
their caliber or the use of new metals.
One day, Saar comes across a bomb
in the shrubs. A dud. Obviously, the propeller of the detonator
had malfunctioned.
On the tour I had two RAF corporals and in a democratic sense
I said to these two guys, "Are you happy that we take
this unexploded bomb,"
it was about this big, "back to Berlin?" And they said, "yep, fine."
Yet it's a long haul to Berlin. Will the bomb be stable enough
to withstand one and a half hours on the notoriously cobbled roads
of East Germany?
In the end, they make it back in one piece and present their prey to their superiors. The brigadier suddenly was there
and he said,
"What have you got there, Rod?"
Because we had a tarpaulin. "Unexploded bomb, sir." "Oh," he said.
[laughing] So, we went into
the Air Force operations room. We laid it on a long table. We took the tarpaulin off...
and all my colleagues went! [laughs] So... [chuckles] Then the ordnance people came.
They took the bomb away.
I was then going on holiday. I said, "Okay, dismantle the bomb,
I want to take photographs." Which I did.
When I came back, they told me, "Well, this bomb was unstable. Please don't bring any more
unexploded bombs."
End of story. [laughs] I wouldn't do it today, by the way!
[laughs] [narrator] Saar doesn't think of himself
as a spy.
They were mere collectors
of military Intelligence, he says, with the occasional foray into diplomacy. As in April 1966...
when a Soviet jet crashes into a lake
in the British sector of West Berlin. It's a Yak-28, back then the most modern supersonic
interceptor of the Soviet Air Force.
To Western intelligence
it's an opportunity not be missed. The Yak had taken off in Finowfurt
near Eberswalde. At the local air force museum
there still is one on display.
Klaus-Peter Kobbe has dug into the story
behind the crash. It was the starting point
of an ingenious intelligence operation. [translation from German] The British
began analyzing the wreck straight away.
The parts still visible above the surface told them exactly what they had
before them. And, being experts,
they realized immediately
that they should salvage parts
of the jet engine, and above all, retrieve the components
of the airborne radar. So, the Brits drag their feet.
The RAF experts need time
to lift the secrets of the Yak. The Soviets protest. The British Military Mission
is called in to diffuse the tension.
As it gets dark, their stomachs
are severely tested, but the Brits gain precious time
for their technicians. [laughing] I had to drink lots
of East German brandy
with the two Soviet Air Force colonels
in their jeep. And they said, "We must eat!" And from underneath the seat
they pulled out this dirty cardboard box
which had cold liver and garlic. [laughs] I had to eat and drink
this dreadful stuff!
The stalling tactics pay off. Meanwhile, an elaborate effort
has been launched to recover the Yak's vital components
from the crash site.
The divers floated them underwater,
the engines and the radar, for about two miles round, where they were taken out of the water
and flown back to England for evaluation.
[interviewer] Yeah. Having evaluated, they were flown back. The divers floated them back again
and one came up and said,
"We have found the engines!" [laughs] A whole week passes
before the engines are returned. As for the airborne radar,
the British claim
that they couldn't find it. The Soviets do not believe them. Moscow is said to have ordered
the replacement
of all modules of their
friend foe identification electronics, as well as all relevant codes,
throughout their air force. [jet engines whine]
It's an immense effort, yet unavoidable, since the Yak pilot didn't push the button that would have
ignited an explosive cartridge.
This would have destroyed the radar set and the coding block. [speaking German]
We asked the people at the factory
who had developed those components what might have happened
if the crew had survived the crash. They told us that they would
probably have faced a court martial
which might well have resulted
in a death sentence. Since the crew perished with their plane, they escape any legal consequences
of their failure.
They are even declared heroes. According to the official version,
they had given their lives to prevent their jet crashing
into a housing area.
Boris Kapustin and Viktor Janov
are buried with full military honors. Up until then, the only thing that mattered
had been to get hold
of the Yak's secret equipment. The surroundings of Potsdam have always
been considered prime locations. A fact that the military missions
were well aware of.
Images of the Villa Colonel,
filmed in the 1980s, when it was the seat of the French
Military Mission in East Germany. [speaking French]
[translation]
To us, the villa was a corner of France. A place where you could feel
comparatively safe. Today, it is used by the ambassador
of Ecuador.
The missions of the Western Allies
worked closely together, and there were official receptions
where everyone met. [indistinct chatter]
Like here, during a reception
staged by the French to celebrate the 14th of July,
their national holiday. Events like these are reserved
for diplomatic small talk
and celebrating peaceful relations. It was interesting to observe
the Soviets from up close. I was very impressed by how much
they could drink.
Summer parties at the villa
are considerably more relaxed affairs. There is a barbecue, and the members of the missions
have brought their families along.
Scenes of an easy-going life
at the shores of a lake. [laughter] No one would suspect that these men
are savvy collectors
of military intelligence who in no time could switch
from diplomatic niceties to covert action hot on the trail
of their enemy.
Sigurd Weber and her brother Jens
are retracing their personal history. The banks of the Elbe River near Magdeburg
had been their childhood playground. And it was at this very spot,
that Sigurd Weber did coolly approach
a Soviet soldier to sound him out about pontoon bridges. That's now almost half a century ago,
when Sigurd was a so-called
"travel spy" for the BND, West Germany's
foreign intelligence service. [speaking German]
[translation] I knew exactly
what information I was looking for. I said kuda, meaning "where to?" He looked at me, and then he explained
what they were doing,
stuta, what this was all about. He was really quite naive.
He just explained everything to me. Bridge laying trucks figure prominently
in the BND's handbook for spies.
Engineer units of the Soviet Army are
a prime target for western reconnaissance. How quickly they can cross a river
is valuable strategic information. It helps to assess
the potential rate of advance
of the Warsaw Pact's armored forces. Sigurd Weber, her late husband
and her brother Jens were amateur spies. They were not in it for the money,
but had chosen to do their bit to overcome a state which kept its
citizens locked behind an Iron Curtain. [quiet chatter in German]
In 1954, Sigurd Weber
and her future husband left East Germany
and settled in Hamburg. In the mid-sixties they were approached
by the BND
and asked whether they would reconnoiter
military installations in the GDR when visiting their relatives
back home in Magdeburg. Sigurd's brother has stayed behind
in the East
and is, by now, thoroughly frustrated. In 1971, his sister talks him
into joining their tiny spy-ring. Travel spies were the BND's go-to solution
after the building of the Wall.
[speaking German] Up until then,
the BND had recruited stationary watchers. These were citizens of East Germany who
lived close to barracks or training areas,
and would therefore have some insights
into what was going on there. They would document their observations and relay them in secret letters
or sometimes directly
to operatives of the BND. The building of the Wall puts an end
to this practice. 1961 is a bad year
for West German Intelligence, anyway.
In November, Heinz Felfe, the head of the
BND's counter-intelligence department, is exposed as a KGB mole. It's a colossal embarrassment.
The damage was enormous,
since the BND‘s counter-espionage was practically wiped out at a stroke. It took years to rebuild
the counter-intelligence department
to something even approaching
a reliable working order. Felfe, who by 1945 was a lieutenant
in the SS, ends up in the spy trade
after his release from British captivity.
He soon belongs to the inner circle
around Reinhard Gehlen. World War Two had barely ended when the former head of the Wehrmacht's
Foreign Armies East section
offered his expertise to the Americans, who, by now, were keen to establish
an anti-Soviet intelligence service in their zone of occupation.
In December 1947, the so-called
"Gehlen Organization" sets up camp at Pullach near Munich, funded, at first, by the US Army,
and, finally, by the CIA. It's the nucleus of the later BND. Its recruits include
former Wehrmacht officers,
SS men and even diehards of the Gestapo. It's an old boys' network, and security
checks are mostly dispensed with. [translation] These people took their
bread from anyone would offer it.
Their lives had been uprooted, most of them were unable to build a career
in the new, post-war society. Those who had been professional soldiers
had no future at all.
There was no German Army anymore, and, according to the prevailing view,
there should never be one again. So, they took any offers
that came their way.
Re-tracking Felfe's activities
reveals treason on an alarming scale. The damage is far worse
than initially suspected. [translation] In their post-fact analysis,
the CIA estimated that Felfe
had blown the cover of about a hundred of their agents. [narrator] As well as 94 German informers
of the BND.
In 1963, Felfe is sentenced
to 14 years in prison. Barely six years later, during a spy swap,
he is sent back to East Germany. Once there, he is resettled
by his masters,
becoming a highly respected
professor of criminology. East German propaganda portrays him
as a staunch activist for world peace and as someone who joined the right cause
after an inner conversion.
[translation] I had to act the way I did. For me, it was about learning the lessons
of the past. I had to join the side which,
as was my conviction,
could never be the cause
of another war in Europe. A self-justification with scant awareness
or regrets for the agents he left exposed, and who the KGB may well have liquidated.
To historians,
Felfe remains a contradiction and an opportunist of the highest order. Presumably, he just sold himself
to the highest bidder.
He was a classic turn-coat. To him, status was immensely important,
the recognition he got. So, his motives were neither purely
financial nor purely ideological.
A cynical master
of deception and betrayal. A man who never queries the actions
of his masters in Moscow, not even as Soviet tanks roll in
to crush the Prague Spring.
In August 1968, Moscow smashes any hopes of "socialism with a human face"
in Czechoslovakia. Western intelligence services
are caught by surprise.
CIA memos had doubted Moscow's willingness
to risk an invasion. Nearly one hundred Czechs and Slovaks,
as well as 50 soldiers are killed. The message is clear. Moscow will
tolerate neither reform nor opposition.
[indistinct shouting] An armored recovery vehicle
of the East German Army, built on a chassis of a T-72.
Time for some tank nostalgia on the grounds of former Soviet barracks
near Magdeburg. An armored personnel carrier,
the type Lawrence G. Kelley, Nigel Dunkley and Jean-Paul Staub
once spotted by the hundreds. In the middle of the 1980s,
NATO could probably only have responded
to an all-out offensive
by Warsaw Pact forces with a nuclear counter strike. The new T-80 was a formidable weapon.
A prime target for military snoopers. And a most dangerous one. [tank tracks rumbling]
Somebody had the clever idea that we should find out
the chemical properties of the new armor on such vehicles as T-80.
Simple! Simple. Simple? They just said, "It's okay,
just scrape the paint away."
And then take a diamond cutter, I still have one, I still have mine,
sorry about that. [laughs] Take a diamond cutter and then
scrape a sliver of the metal
away from the front glacis plate
of the tank, and then put it in a container
and then take it home. In theory at least.
Yet then as now, fortune favors the bold. A British soldier on a Soviet tank. A photograph displaying secret technology,
with an apple showing
its comparative size. A T-80 with a new kind of reactive armor. Small boxes containing explosives
which were intended to blow up
any oncoming projectiles
before they impacted. One of our exceptional tour NCOs, displaying a great deal
of presence of mind and decisiveness,
clambered onto the train,
removed a small box of explosive reactive armor from a T-80, then quickly dismounted,
re-entered the vehicle and the tour sped off to West Berlin. [engine rumbles]
It‘s a significant coup in the arms race
between East and West. 1970. A military parade in Magdeburg. Jens Leck and Sigurd Weber
are on a mission from the BND,
counting military equipment. [translation] We had been told
to be on the lookout for missile vehicles. There weren't many to be seen,
but we managed to spot some.
They were all tracked vehicles
with different configurations. We had been trained to register
if they were old or new, what type of tracks they had,
or how many axles.
Monitoring the strength of the
other side's forces is Cold War routine. Yet numbers alone won't do when assessing
the potential enemy's capabilities. To get a clear picture
of his combat readiness,
it takes observers on the ground. The city of Magdeburg is of
special interest for western intelligence. It's the headquarters
of the 3rd Soviet Army.
For travel spies, a ride on Magdeburg's
streetcars is one of the safer ways to get a glimpse into Soviet barracks. -[Weber] That's line six!
-[Leck] I told you.
It's still running! Line six. [narrator] The line is still operating. The barracks have long been demolished.
There was just a short stretch
at the turning bay up there, where you could look inside.
But only if you were standing. The Webers have been thoroughly trained
for this kind of covert observation.
They are not to take any notes. One of them will inconspicuously observe
what's happening inside the barracks while the other keeps watch for any
security officers among the passengers.
An ever-present risk back then. [translation] The State Security,
Stasi for short, had planted a ring of unofficial informers
around any military object.
They would count, photograph or film
whatever went on. Anything that might be suspicious
is recorded, even if it is only a car
with a Western license plate.
Taking photographs near military
installations is strictly prohibited. Even passers-by are scrutinized. A mother with her buggy might be a spy.
Or a daughter taking a walk with her
father while on a visit from the West. This way dozens of travel spies
were caught in the act. Sigurd Weber and her brother Jens
are arrested in April 1978.
Her husband didn't come along this time
and is spared the ordeal. It has never been precisely established
how their cover was blown. Sigurd Weber suspects a mole
within the Federal Intelligence Service.
Her brother presumes
that the State Security had cracked the address they had used to keep in secret contact
with their controller at the BND.
The day we intended to leave,
my car was damaged. So, I drove to the police headquarters to get a complaint
for my insurance company in Hamburg.
When I was stopped on the way, I naturally thought
it was because of the damage to my car. Some windows were broken,
a side mirror had been ripped off.
So, I thought they had stopped me
because of that. I had to leave my car
and hand over my keys. I was coaxed into a Wartburg.
The doors were locked at once, and there I was,
sitting between two female constables. I refused to believe it at first,
but then I thought, "this is it."
Days of interrogation follow. There is no use denying the charges,
the Stasi already has proof. For Sigurd Weber,
it suddenly becomes clear.
Her controller's assurances
that they need not expect any trouble had been nothing more than words. When my brother got 15 years,
I said, "Well, that'll be life for me."
But my interrogator said, "No, we also chop off heads." Sigurd is spared the worst.
Yet even a life sentence comes as a shock. She is unaware of any agent swaps and
must face the prospect of life in prison. [Weber] Everything was bad.
But the isolation really hit me.
Loneliness is terror. In retrospect, that really was the worst. There was no one to communicate with,
I was always alone,
in solitary confinement. And they knew that you could break
a person's psyche like that. She is released after three years
thanks to another spy swap.
The following year,
her brother is sent back to the West. The Webers were hunting for
the tiniest parts of the overall puzzle, mere ants in the vast world
of global espionage.
But there are times when a single agent can undermine the security
of a whole nation. The treason committed
by John Anthony Walker
is considered to be so devastating that, after his exposure,
he spends the rest of his life in prison. He dies in 2014, in the 30th year
of his confinement.
Walker begins his career in the US Navy
and is trained as a wireless operator. He is then posted to the headquarters
of the strategic submarine fleet. While he is only a tiny cog
in the communication network
of the world's most powerful navy, he now has access
to the most sensitive information. He is working in the field of
communication technology and cipher codes.
In 1967, Petty Officer Walker begins to cash in
on this highly confidential information. To him it was a business.
He was solely out for money, and there was
no political or ideological motivation. He wanted money, and he knew
that he could demand a high price. [narrator] Walker's approach
is as direct as possible.
He copies some secret documents,
drives to Washington DC, walks into the Soviet Embassy
and offers the KGB a deal. Money in exchange for secret codes
used by the US Navy
to encipher their communication. To the Soviets it's a goldmine. They will be able to trace exercises
of US Navy units,
analyze overall strategies, and collect data
about weapon systems on board. From now on,
the Soviets will be listening in.
[electronic beeping] And what's more, Walker also enables
Moscow to pry into the Holy Grail
of the American's nuclear arsenal,
the operations
of their strategic submarines who are prowling the depths of the oceans
along secret routes, ready to launch their nuclear missiles.
A submarine is a lone wolf,
silently moving under water without anyone knowing its whereabouts. That is its protection and, of course,
also an essential element
of nuclear deterrence. If this secrecy is compromised,
that is, if an enemy penetrates the communication
systems of your own submarine fleet,
then all its movements would be disclosed and the fleet itself would be
next to useless. Walker escapes the radar of American
counter-espionage for almost two decades.
A man who sold the security of his nation
solely for greed. When he is finally exposed, it's a revelation
of nightmarish proportions.
What brought him down
was a purely private matter. His ex-wife, they divorced in 1976, feared that he would entangle
their adult children in his spy business.
And so, she rang the FBI. To her it was bad enough that her husband
was such a nasty piece of work, but as she said, at least I won't let
my children go to the dogs.
For her son Michael, however,
it's too late. He's allowed himself
to be lured into his father's activities and is sentenced to 15 years in prison.
Vietnam, at the end of the sixties. The US Army is engaged in a war
against the communist North. In its effort to contain the spread
of communism in East Asia,
the US administration makes but poor use
of its intelligence services. [gunfire] Memos on enemy strength and morale are
often nothing more than wishful thinking
while reports tend to overestimate the effect of American firepower
in the jungle. Even highly sophisticated spy jets
like the SR-71 Blackbird
do not bring about a decisive change although their crews run the gauntlet
almost daily to reconnoiter North Vietnamese air
defense and to identify strategic targets.
The enemy defies any effort
to bomb them into submission. In the end, the superpower loses the war which had claimed
almost three million lives
and became overshadowed
by atrocities and massacres. The outcome is a bitter pill
for an administration which had misused
their intelligence services
to supply its leaders with the information
they wanted to hear. It's a busy day in the air above Welzow,
south of Cottbus. That's why Rod Saar is there,
along with his team.
It's early September 1972. But the Brits aren't alone. Corporal Calvin said, "There is somebody
in there in this low pine."
We're in low pine trees. I said, "Fine." Everybody in the car. Car locked, equipment away.
"I will investigate." Saar suspects them to be
operatives of the Stasi, East Germany's State Security forces.
Usually, the missions don't really
care about them. They may call in the Soviets,
but that would merely be a nuisance. My tactic with the Stasi
was always to chase them.
Aggressively. If I knew the Stasi were hiding,
I would run at them. And I'd run, I'd charge, I'd shout.
Standard aggressive tactic. And this worked.
They would run, they would go. But this time, the men in the bushes
aren't Stasi.
They are Soviet Special Forces. They changed their tactic.
They used... Each airfield in the end had Speznia
platoons, special forces platoons,
and they are trying to jump you and their aim, basically,
was to be violent. The Speznya or Spetsnaz are among
the toughest troops on either side.
Elite units, trained not to back down. At first, they merely observe the British
as they move about near the air base. Then Rod Saar tries his usual tactic
on them.
They rose up, I ran back. Too late. They got me. A Kalashnikov stuck in my neck.
Okay, so you don't move, okay. Got to the car, smashed the car window, knocked out Corporal Calvin,
didn't touch the group captain,
but stole our equipment. Rod Saar is declared persona non grata
by the Soviets. It's the end of his forays
into East Germany.
He has pushed his luck too far this time. A powerful engine is a trump card
on the Allied missions' tours. Superior speed helps to shake off
any shadowers
or, if need be, to make a getaway,
be it on the road or on rough terrain. By stepping on the gas, you could leave
the State Security standing in the dust. [engine accelerates]
Burkhard Mielke was among those
who often came out on the losing end of such encounters. During the 1980s,
he works for East Germany's directorate
for counter-intelligence. At times, they were speeding along
at up to 220 kilometers per hour. With our Wartburgs and Ladas,
we didn't stand a chance.
The specially modified mission cars
have a range of 1,000 kilometers, whereas a Wartburg would have to refuel
twice to cover that distance. Stasi photographs
of a mission tour filling up,
showing the size of the additional tank. Cool and composed,
these Allied mission officers channel the nonchalant spirit
of the easy riders.
Protected by their status and horsepower while their Eastern shadowers
record their activities on film. [speaking German]
[translation] Later on, we gave up
chasing after them and set up reception committees instead. The missions must now reckon with
Stasi units
lying in wait along their tour. Their opponents know from experience
where and when the Western snoopers
will most probably show up.
Every directorate was trying
to impress the ministry. We said, "today is the big day,
we'll capture a mission car, get hold of their equipment
and teach them a lesson."
Every unit wanted to be the first
to achieve this. And so, we came up with a few ideas
of our own. It had been decided that State Security
should no longer simply record
the missions' activities but actually prevent them. Unbeknownst to the men on the tours,
the rules of the game had been changed.
The driver's cab of a truck still arouses
painful memories for Jean-Paul Staub. [engine running] -To this day...
-[echoing screech]
...it reminds him of an incident
overshadowing his years as a tour officer
for the French military mission. 1984...
north of the city of Halle. Three days before, a Ural,
a heavy truck of the East German Army, took up position in a side road.
It is apparently waiting
for the order to move. [man on radio] Maintain your position.
Everything according to plan. Roger.
-[engine starts]
-[narrator] At about 11 o'clock, on March 22nd,
the Stasi prepares to strike. It's target,
a car of the French military mission
on its way to observe a major exercise of
the Warsaw Pact forces in East Germany. Jean-Paul Staub is riding in the back. We did notice an army jeep
coming up from behind.
It seemed like he was
intending to chase us. But we were in front, so we sped up a bit, and, under normal circumstances,
we would have got away.
But it's a trap. Suddenly there's a truck ahead of them. It's the Ural.
[driver speaks French] [narrator] And it's behaving
in a most threatening manner. [speaking French]
[translation] I said to Warrant Officer
Mariotti, who was our driver, "Stop, we won't get past him." But I may not have been forceful enough.
Anyway, in critical situations, it's the driver who knows best
which decision to take. Both drivers step on the gas.
The soldier in the Ural is determined
to block the French car come what may. The result is a fatal crash. Stills from the accident
filed by State Security.
The truth is, Mariotti nearly made it. One or two seconds earlier,
and we would have got past the truck and sped off towards Halle.
But sadly, it wasn't to be. Mariotti died on the spot. I was severely injured,
and our third man, Warrant Officer
Blancheton, had a broken shoulder. No less than three trucks had been
positioned ahead of the French vehicle with a view to catching them red-handed
in their illicit activities.
[speaking German] I'm no lawyer. Yet to me,
the term “negligent homicide” seems applicable here.
They obviously knew
someone might get killed, yet they went ahead regardless. After all, the cars involved weren't
little Trabants, made of plastic,
but heavy trucks. Philippe Mariotti acted on
his driver's instinct, as he had done many times before.
For once, he misjudged the situation. The French Government tries
to keep the incident out of the headlines. Both sides are pursuing a policy
of military de-escalation.
The death of a soldier must not get
in the way of international diplomacy. He was buried discreetly
without military honors. An ignominious end
to the life of a soldier.
The garden of the former
French military mission in Potsdam. In remembrance of Warrant Officer
Mariotti, a memorial stone has been laid. His comrades leave their wreaths
at the site of his death.
An act that, too, is duly recorded
by State Security cameramen. [narrator] Nigel Dunkley,
a veteran of the British Military Mission, in a hangar near Jüterbog,
a small town south of Potsdam.
He's meeting up with Manfred Müller
of the local garrison society. Dunkley is telling him about his missions. About reconnaissance tours
in enemy territory at night.
Manfred Müller has several items
in his museum that were high on the British
Military Mission's wish list in the 1980s. The officers of
the Allied Military Liaison Missions
were constantly on the road. As couriers with a diplomatic passport,
their original task was to solve problems between
the four occupying powers in Germany.
However, they soon exploit their freedom
by spying on their opponents: the Soviets in Western Germany and the Americans, British and French
in the East,
the German Democratic Republic. Each side is allowed to send out 63 men. An all-terrain vehicle is approaching
a Soviet bunker.
It is the early 1980s. The British are on the hunt
for new types of ammunition that could contain biological
or chemical warfare agents.
The bunker should only be manned
during military exercises. The intruders can't be completely
sure of that, however. They have reached the room
that holds the air filters.
How these filters are constructed
tells experts which warfare agent
they are supposed to protect against. Nigel Dunkley takes part in the hunt
for these filters.
In Jüterbog he sees
the once highly coveted barrels again. Dunkley never talks about the background
of his missions. Most of it is still top secret.
He only talks about what he experienced. It was dark.
I dropped the filter that I was removing. The guard heard that, his dog barked.
And so I ran away as fast I could. There's no other expression for it. [narrator] NATO insists on speeding up
the investigation.
How are the Soviet filters constructed? What warfare agents did the Soviets
prepare for in an emergency? Could it be types of agents
the West does not know of yet?
In 1982, at a military exercise area, the British get their hands
on the first filter. The news of the captured barrel
hits the Ministry of Defence in London
like a bombshell. The filter apparently protects against
germs as well, biological particles being scattered
by grenades, for example.
In response, NATO is said to launch
a research programme to upgrade their own filters. Of course we knew...
...that anything, that was important
that we "borrowed," as we would say, um, would probably pretty quickly
be replaced.
And so a few weeks later we went back
and there was the brand new one. That was the one that we wanted.
So we stole that as well. [chuckles]
[narrator] Afghanistan. Soviet troops have been occupying
the country since December 1979. Moscow wants to break any resistance
against the communist regime
that has been installed in Kabul. The insurgent Mujahideen appear powerless
in the face of full Soviet firepower. Attack helicopters dominate
the battlefield.
Yet secretly the Americans are supporting
Islamist resistance groups in Afghanistan. The war at the Hindu Kush turns into
yet another theatre of operations for the secret services.
[speaking German] [interpreter] The CIA
launched "Operation Cyclone," which is one of the longest
and most expensive CIA operations to date.
In all, the cost of this covert program, which included arms delivery
as well as economic aid, amounted to several billion dollars.
[narrator]
This money mostly flows to Pakistan, the central hub for the armament
of the Mujahideen. The CIA also supplies them
with modern
Stinger anti-aircraft missiles. The tide is starting to turn. With Stinger missiles, the Mujahideen
can shoot down jets and helicopters.
Soviet troops sustain severe casualties. In the mountains of Afghanistan, the superpower's heavy arms
are ineffective.
The alliance of Mujahideen
and the CIA win the war. The US bolster a partner
who will soon turn against them, while the Soviet Union
loses a lot of prestige.
Roughly one million people die, 15,000 Soviet soldiers among them. Hind attack helicopters
fly over East Germany.
Scouts from a western military mission
observe a manoeuvre. The war in Afghanistan deepens the divide
between East and West. Soviet troops exercise
new attack strategies.
The Hind pilots impressed me,
and I was an attack pilot as well, albeit in jets rather than helos. They flew low,
aggressively, and maintained
positive control over their aircraft. I doubt that our own helo pilots
could have flown better than many of the Hind pilots that I saw.
[narrator] The military mission's task
is to find out whether the Soviets are deploying combat units
from East Germany to Afghanistan. They need to produce information,
no matter how they get it.
The officers with diplomatic passports put on thigh-length overboots
and protective gloves. None of them know what they
will have to touch that night.
They check their flashlights
one last time. The barracks' rubbish tip is their target. But they are not alone.
The smallest noise could give
the scouts away and alert the guard. Examining rubbish tips at night was part
of the British "Operation Tomahawk"... activities which had been classified
top secret until just recently.
[metallic rattling] A noise alerts the guard,
the snoopers scan the area. Could there be a second guard?
It is just a stray dog. All clear. However, scouts feared dogs
on night missions,
as Nigel Dunkley remembers. [Nigel Dunkley] There were
quite often wild dogs out on the rubbish tips.
These dogs scared me.
And I don't mind admitting it. One of them, I remember, came up to me,
like they often did, and started sniffing around my leg.
And I thought, this dog must have rabies.
It's not acting properly. [narrator] A single dog can put
the men in danger. After half an hour, the guard finally
gets in his Jeep and drives off.
With the way to the rubbish tip clear, the British scouts are hoping
for discarded datasheets on tanks, duty rosters, notepads
and maybe evidence
for missions in Afghanistan. Instead, they find rotting kitchen waste. While methodically feeling around
for something useful for their analysts,
they get lucky: a grubby postcard
with a field post number. They know that such numbers
are the key to an army's structure and to its order of battle
in the event of war.
Soldiers have numbers,
just like the units they serve in... and the tanks they are scheduled
to fight in in an emergency. That's routine business
to the military missions.
A seemingly endless roster of digits
on tens of thousands of vehicles that is often boring but important. [man] N883, so first one was 882.
[narrator] Heavily armed men
are protecting a visitor to the cemetery. Ryszard Kukliński,
a former officer and traitor in the general staff of the Polish army,
fears a revenge attack.
He is visiting his parents' grave
in 1998, one year after his death sentence
for treason has been reversed and he has been rehabilitated.
[speaking German] [interpreter] Ryszard Kukliński passed on
documents on the Warsaw Pact to the Americans
for nine years from 1972 to 1981.
With these almost 350,000
photographed documents, he provided the Americans
with in-depth knowledge on the Soviet side
of the Warsaw Pact.
[narrator] Kukliński contacts the CIA in the hopes of reducing the risk
of a nuclear war. A war in which Poland would
become a battlefield as well.
He reveals military installations
and strategies of the Warsaw Pact. [speaking German] [interpreter] The Americans were wondering
whether the Soviet nuclear arsenal
was intended to serve as a threat or whether they would use it
in an attack on western Europe. And Kukliński's documents indicated
that the Russians
were indeed using their nuclear potential
offensively as well. [narrator] Poland in the late 1970s. The labour union "Solidarity"
is challenging the communist regime.
Kukliński cautions against
a Soviet invasion into Poland, reporting plans to declare martial law
to the CIA. When it is finally imposed
in December 1981,
the defector has already
escaped to the United States. Hiding in boxes, Kukliński,
his wife and their two sons are smuggled out of the country
via East Berlin by the CIA.
In a transporter, disguised
as diplomatic baggage, they escape at the last minute. [speaking German]
[interpreter] In 1984 he was sentenced
to death in absentia. The sentence was not reversed until 1997, long after the Warsaw Pact
had been disbanded
and Poland was no longer
a communist country. Kukliński was controversial,
because there was dispute over Poland's status in the Cold War.
Was it a sovereign state? If so, Kukliński
would have betrayed Poland and could be considered a traitor
even today.
Or was it just a puppet of the Soviets and Kukliński had therefore only betrayed
the occupying power? [narrator] Ryszard Kukliński does not
fall prey to an act of revenge.
In 2004, he dies of a stroke
in his exile in the US. To the present day,
he is a controversial figure in Poland. The Warsaw Pact is not the only victim
of a master spy however.
NATO is as well. This spy's employer
is the Ministry for State Security of the GDR, the Stasi.
His codename is "Topaz,"
his real name is Rainer Rupp. As a spy, he makes no mistakes. It is not until 1993
that he is arrested and put on trial.
Rupp had been releasing top secret
documents on NATO's military strategy and armament plans
to East Germany since 1977. [man speaking German]
[interpreter] Rainer Rupp had access
to documents you can only dream of. Key documents from NATO headquarters. They were so fantastic,
the Ministry of State Security
immediately passed them on to the KGB
the minute they received them. [narrator]
Rupp is a spy by political conviction. He is sentenced to 12 years
on charges of high treason,
which could have been disastrous
in the case of a conflict, as the opinion of the court stated. NATO is working towards its nuclear
re-armament in the late 1970s,
yet nobody suspects Moscow to have gained
this intelligence via its mole "Topaz." Nigel Dunkley on the premises
of a former military hospital in Beelitz, a place that still haunts him.
About 30 years ago, he was secretly
rummaging through the trash from the operating theatres. [Dunkley] There was a sickly sweet,
disgusting, rotten smell.
[narrator] The Beelitz Sanatoriums
were built in the late 19th and early 20th century. After World War II, the Soviets move in.
In the 1980s,
the military mission's interest in hospitals of the Soviet military
is growing. That's especially true for the British,
who are hoping that, in Beelitz,
they will gain new information
on the war in Afghanistan. The Soviets suffer severe casualties
in the Hindu Kush. It is quite possible
that some of their wounded
were treated in Germany as well. [explosions] The British want to get to the bottom
of that assumption.
That is why Dunkley is sent to Beelitz, on some of the most depressing
field trips he has ever been on. The Military Missions did not have access
to the sanatorium itself,
only to its rubbish tip. Coming back to this place
after all these years still is a very emotional experience.
When I think of what happened here, when I think what went on, the number of people who suffered here
from the Soviet army.
For me still, all these years later, it is
still a very, very moving experience. [narrator] The operating theatres
lie in ruins, but it only takes a few of the remnants
to send Dunkley back
on a journey through time. A medicine cabinet
in the anaesthesia department provides a window into the past.
[Dudley] Wow. Absolutely amazing
to find these medicines here. [narrator] Dunkley contemplates the fate
of patients and the work of the doctors.
[Dunkley] It's extraordinary to think... that while the Russians were doing
their surgical preparation in here in the operating theatre,
we, at the same time, are out there waiting for the blood-stained bits
of uniform, for the bandages covered in mess
and bits and pieces,
body parts even, from time to time. We're waiting there, as it was described,
"like vultures on a branch." [narrator] For hours,
they are on standby at the disposal site.
They want to know where
the fresh bags are being dumped. As soon as the dust cart leaves,
their work starts. Dunkley discovers remains
of amputated tissue in a boot.
A find that upsets him. [Dunkley] I did this
for two and a half years. You can't do this kind of stuff without,
after a while, it has an effect on you.
You begin to think,
in your quieter moments, what you have found,
and then you begin to wonder about the fate of the young person
whose jacket pocket you looked through. [narrator] Going through waste is hardly
a new method in the business of espionage. That the missions employ it as well
remains a well-kept secret
for quite some time. They are rummaging for papers
and letters, systematically looking for them
in the pockets of discarded uniforms.
[Dunkley] In a uniform jacket pocket, there was this letter that said...
"Dear Mum... Dear Mother,
I think I'm the last one left. We were attacked recently. It was terrible.
I think I'm the only survivor
of that ambush by the Taliban." And that had a really big impact
when you start to think what happened to the soldier,
because the letter was never finished.
[narrator] How many soldiers
who were wounded in Afghanistan were treated in Beelitz is disputed. There probably were individual cases,
Soviet soldiers who had been detailed
there from East Germany. Hospital waste can reveal quite a lot,
even without war wounded: about medical standards
or protection against infections.
All of that is relevant
for the combat strength of an army. In the late 1970s, the Cold War undergoes
its next dangerous escalation. Each SS-20 carries three nuclear warheads
and could reach any location
in Western Europe from Russia. A nuclear conflict confined
only to Europe is looming. It might be an alternative
for the superpowers,
but it would mean the end for Germany. In West Berlin,
the ruin of a listening post shrouded in mystery is rotting away.
Its protective sheathing in tatters,
its antennae dismantled. Helmut Müller-Enbergs,
an expert on secret services, is imagining the babble of voices
on the airwaves
that the spies on the Teufelsberg,
the devil's hill, used to listen to. [Helmut speaking German] [interpreter] They don't know
what's happening in the East,
but from this location they can take
a peek at the desks of their enemy, so to speak. Where are tanks being moved,
where are manoeuvres being conducted,
what is going on? [narrator] The Americans and the British
use Teufelsberg as a base for spying. Fifteen hundred personnel intercept,
translate and analyse in shifts.
Their antennae pick up communications
several hundred miles away. [speaking German] [interpreter] If there hadn't been sources
or agents of the Stasi here,
we probably still would not know
who was on duty here or how many of them there were, and we wouldn't know what was recorded.
[narrator] Teufelsberg is one station
in a global network operated by
the National Security Agency, or NSA. An effective squad of eavesdroppers that,
in the early '80s, is still top secret.
However, that is about to change. With James William Hall,
a US soldier working at Teufelsberg. In 1982, Hall begins passing on
secret documents
on the American eavesdropping operations
to the KGB and the Stasi. Among them were long lists
of the NSA's targets. Hall's photocopier is running hot.
He and his associate
are said to wear sunglasses, so they can keep the copier's lid open
and therefore work faster. Even a classified document
with the code name "Canopy Wing"
is sent to East Berlin that way. [Helmut speaking German] [interpreter] "Canopy Wing" has to be
the best piece of intelligence
the Stasi was ever able to gather. Unfortunately, we cannot read
the documents today. We only have their projections,
statements and hints about them.
But with all the speculation combined,
we can assume that the State Security Service
had the ingredients required for a pre-emptive nuclear strike.
They had a strategy for electronic combat. [narrator] Hall betrays how NATO
would communicate in the case of an emergency,
and how they want to disrupt
the Warsaw Pact's communications. The Stasi describes how the West wants
to manipulate radio communications between pilots and control centres
on the ground,
strategies that must have
been unsettling for Moscow. In the chaos surrounding the Stasi's files
after the reunification of Germany, insiders secure
the "Canopy Wing" documents.
In 1992, the Kohl administration hands them over to the US
without causing a stir. Hall's cover is blown in 1988
and he is sentenced to 40 years in prison.
Jeffrey Carney betrays the NSA as well. He doesn't do it for money
but for conscientious reasons. His punishment: 38 years in prison.
He is released after almost 12 years. In 1983, Carney is a soldier
in the Air Force, stationed at the NSA field site
in Marienfelde, Berlin.
That is where he learned about operations
which still disgust him today. [speaking German] [interpreter] We didn't simply
want to provoke the "sleepy guys"
on the other side
to see what they would do. We actually wanted to set off the alarm,
literally the alarm. For those who don't know, that means
we were planning to provoke the Russians
into thinking it was the real thing. Think about what that means: an actual alert, 1983, the Cold War,
"Able Archer."
[narrator] Carney provides
only vague hints. No details. He might have to go back to prison
if he were more specific.
Fire! The command post exercise "Able Archer" is the highlight of the annual
autumn manoeuvres.
Just like every year, NATO practices the defence of Western Europe
against an attack. [soldier] Move forward!
Get down, get down! [narrator] The deployment of troops
for training purposes has been a routine exercise
since the 1960s.
But in 1983, Moscow has reason to follow the autumnal manoeuvres
with particular suspicion. This year, NATO relocates
40,000 troops in Europe,
and 16,000 are flown in
from the US in silent missions. In early November, the command post
exercise "Able Archer" follows. Its scenario: NATO responds
to poison gas attacks by its enemy
with a nuclear strike. It also practices new procedures
of nuclear release. There is evidence that Moscow
misunderstood "Able Archer"
as the initial phase
of an imminent nuclear attack. An officer in the British Military Mission
later reports that Soviet "Backfire" atom bombers,
seen here in original footage
of their take-off, had been stationed in East Germany
during "Able Archer." Was it just a routine stop-over?
Or were the bombers ready
for a counter attack? "Able Archer" is going to plan. Then, a double agent sends reports
about flash telegrams in Moscow
saying NATO bases were on alert. The West recognizes
the misunderstanding and reacts. The agent who warns NATO
is Oleg Gordievsky,
a colonel in the KGB and a mole for the British Secret
Intelligence Service. He has been betraying secrets since 1974.
The "Able Archer" crisis makes him famous. [speaking German] [interpreter] There was great danger
that bad decisions would be made.
With intercontinental ballistic missiles, which take just 30 minutes
to reach the other side, there is no time to think or to conduct
an organized decision-making process.
[narrator] Since the early '80s, the Kremlin's fear of a first strike
by NATO has been growing. Yuri Andropov, the terminally ill
General Secretary of the Communist Party,
orders the secret services to look for
evidence that the West is preparing a war. Moscow readies its nuclear arsenal,
as classified US documents prove. The number of redacted passages
suggests that "Able Archer"
was not as harmless as Washington
still makes it out to be. [speaking German] [interpreter] Gordievsky was able
to plausibly explain
and convey the dilemma and the psychological state
of those involved. That was his real achievement,
describing what was going on
in the apparatuses and in people's minds, making clear that the Soviet leaders
were frightened and concerned
and needed to be treated
with consideration to prevent fatal decisions. [narrator] NATO takes Gordievsky's
message seriously
and abandons certain parts
of "Able Archer." In 1985 Gordievsky comes under suspicion. He flees Moscow by train
and is smuggled into the West
by the British Secret Service. Today he is living near London. [speaking German]
[interpreter] Among the many defectors
in the Cold War who went from the East to the West, Gordievsky was one of the few
we can ascribe idealistic motives to.
He really did want to keep the peace,
for both sides, and avert a catastrophe. [narrator] Jeffrey Carney sees himself
as a traitor for peace as well. He sees the NSA deliberately
creating confusion within a nuclear power
as reckless. When he comes under suspicion,
he disappears and assumes a new identity with the help
of the East German State Security Service.
Living as "Jens Karney" in East Berlin,
he is captured by US agents in 1991. To this day, he is convinced
he has done the right thing. [speaking German]
[interpreter] Many people were not aware
back then how close to the brink we were. Why should I regret something like this? [narrator] A journey back
to the atomic age
to when the world stood
at the brink of destruction. Nigel Dunkley is visiting the site
of a former storage facility for nuclear warheads.
[Dunkley] Fantastic. Fantastic. Amazing. [narrator] The crane runway to transfer
the warheads is very well preserved.
An air-conditioning system provided
a constant storage temperature. We are at the Special Weapons Site
Linda-Stolzenhain, one hour south of Berlin.
The site used to be a restricted area
and was closely guarded. To Military Missions it was unattainable. Stolzenhain provided space
for 328 nuclear warheads
in two identically structured bunkers. In the ground, there are mountings
to anchor the nuclear weapons. [speaking German]
[interpreter] Each storage facility
has 164 anchoring points. Four points per warhead,
so there were 41 warheads in one depot. [Dunkley] To be underground
in a storage facility
of Soviet nuclear warheads,
over 300 of them, over 300 of them. When you think of the combined
destructive power of so many warheads,
that is absolutely shocking. It is stunning. It is... It's extraordinary.
[narrator] Manfred Müller,
the bunker guide, appears conspicuously well informed. And Dunkley wonders why.
[Dunkley] And so I asked him,
I said, "Manfred, uh, what were you?" And he said: "Ich war Major,
I was a Major." And I said, "Well, that's interesting.
Ich war auch Major, I was a major too."
And then we both laughed. And we both realized that we must
have been exact contemporaries, but exact opposites.
So we were opposite each other. He was for me potentially
a very dangerous person in those days. But here we were laughing, talking.
And the nice thing was,
being very friendly with each other. [speaking German] [interpreter] Two former enemies
who are now friends.
I think that's fantastic. Thank you for the information. You're welcome.
[chuckles] [narrator] Unfortunately, their friendship
only lasts for a short time. A few months later, Manfred Müller dies.
Minsk in Belarus. Fashionable clothes and international
brands of car are everywhere to be seen. Forty years ago, when Vladimir Pazkalev
reported for duty in West Germany,
it was very different. He is a driver
for the Soviet military mission. Having been thrown into the hustle
and bustle of a Western consumer society,
he chauffeurs officers
on their reconnaissance missions. He doesn't think of himself as a spy. [speaking German]
[interpreter] I wouldn't say we spied
on one other, we observed one other. And we kept in touch with the high command
of Soviet Forces in Germany. Who could we observe anyway?
We only monitored troop movements,
as we had no access to restricted areas. [narrator] Aged 21,
he arrives in Bünde, Westphalia, the site of the Soviet military mission,
or SOXMIS, in the British sector.
His main task consists
of reconnaissance missions. They have become routine in the conflict between two blocs
that don't trust each other.
Pazkalev's superiors are officers in the Soviet
military intelligence service. Their mission mirrors
those of the British, the French
and the Americans in East Germany. Cold War routine. Today, Pazkalev is heading
to a meeting with a former comrade.
Myadzye in the Belarus countryside,
three hours from Minsk by car. Sergei Sidorenko is expecting Pazkalev. The two have made contact
via the Internet,
almost 40 years
after their time in Germany. Sergei used to be a driver as well. He was with the mission in Frankfurt.
Today, he is in a wheelchair,
as he lost his leg after a stroke. A great misfortune that forced the long-distance truck driver
into retirement.
[indistinct conversation in German] His photo album reminds him
of a better time, when they were driving
fast cars through Germany.
[speaking German] [interpreter] Did the police
constantly chase you too? Yes, British military
police always followed us.
[narrator] Just like Western missions
did in East Germany, the Soviets operate
within sight of counterintelligence. This is a surveillance video
filmed in Frankfurt.
A few years earlier, it could have been
Sidorenko behind the wheel. US military police are waiting
at the gate. All of a sudden
they take off at full speed.
The car chase is on. The Soviet missions are suspected of conducting intelligence operations
as well.
Such as using dead drops
to pass on classified material. However, there is no proof of this. These car chases are familiar
to Sidorenko,
who finds them to be a nuisance. This photograph shows him
in 1979 near Munich. Soon after, he will find himself
with a gun to his head,
as German armed forces stop him. His officer had been trying to take
pictures of an anti-aircraft system. For hours, he and his officer are trapped,
before the Americans rescue them
from their predicament. [speaking Russian] [interpreter] Of course, we were scared.
Especially when that officer
from the German army was pointing his gun at me. I thought: "That's it,
I'm going to be shot."
And my, up until that point, short life... passed before my eyes. [narrator] Lawrence G. Kelley
is exploring terrain near Neustrelitz.
Former forester Erich Gebauer
provides him with orientation. In 1984, on this country road,
Kelley scored his biggest coup. It's the time of the so-called
"re-armament" in West Germany.
In response to the Soviet SS-20,
NATO deploys Pershing II Missiles. Their nuclear warheads
threaten targets as far as Moscow. The nuclear confrontation
in the middle of Europe intensifies.
The Soviets respond to the Pershings. Night convoys
in East Germany spell trouble. Kelley encounters
one of those at the time.
I attempted to call out the VRNs,
the license plate numbers, for the vehicles in the column,
but there were none. The column was transporting
cylindrical environmental canisters
with very prominent longitudinal ribs, and those ribs were the primary
signature feature for the "Scaleboard" system.
[narrator] The SS-12 Scaleboard
is a well-known missile model, but it has not been seen
in East Germany before. The SS-12 has a range of 560 miles,
enough to pose a nuclear threat to Pershing II sites in West Germany. Kelley is taking pictures
of the ominous canisters
from his tour's moving car. He expects the Soviets
to force him off the road any second. Yet they don't react.
It is only later that it becomes clear
how important his photographs were. They were actually the first ground-level
shots taken of this component of the weapons system at all,
at least in the West.
[narrator] The public does not see
the ribbed canisters of the SS-12 Scaleboard
until they leave East Germany in 1987. One year earlier,
US president Ronald Reagan
and Soviet General Secretary
Mikhail Gorbachev had agreed to eliminate all intermediate
range ballistic missiles from Europe in the INF Treaty.
Not only the SS-12
but also the Pershing II and SS-20 missiles were destroyed. Yet despite the policy of detente
at the highest level,
the spying war continues. Robert Hanssen ranks
as one of the most serious traitors in the history
of US intelligence services.
It takes until 2001 for the FBI
to expose and arrest him. Hanssen holds a key position
in US counterintelligence, a dream position for a KGB mole.
[speaking German] [interpreter] Hanssen is
a devout catholic, he attends church, has a family and several children,
and is a devoted father.
None of that fits the pattern. Traitors usually have broken biographies, somebody who has divorced three times
and is an alcoholic would be more typical.
[narrator] Mere greed is what
drives the supposedly upright citizen. He begins his lucrative
double-dealing in 1979. The investigative authorities estimate
that over the years he has received
$1.4 million in payment. As an intelligence professional, Hanssen knows the pitfalls
of the business and avoids them.
[speaking German] [interpreter] The Soviets didn't know
who he was until he was arrested. He never met with anybody.
He was extremely cautious and very clever. That's why it took so long to find him. [narrator] Hanssen's arrest is a shock
to US counterintelligence.
He disclosed the position
of secret bunkers for the government and information about operations
against the KGB. His worst betrayal, however, was revealing
CIA sources in the Soviet Union
and thereby sending these informants
to their doom. [speaking German] [interpreter] Being this cold blooded,
without showing any external signs,
and committing such a crime,
make him the perfect criminal. He should have been
sentenced to death, but narrowly avoided this fate
by providing comprehensive testimony.
[narrator] Hanssen is sentenced
to 15 consecutive life sentences without the possibility of parole. Aldrich Ames is serving
a life sentence as well.
In exchange for several million dollars
in blood money, he sends US agents
in Moscow to their death. Yet he shows no remorse.
As I get in my car,
as I walk in my house, as I put on an expensive suit, do I have an awareness of blood guilt?
No. No, I didn't. [narrator] He shows no sympathy
for those he has betrayed, even as they are executed by the KGB.
To Ames, death is
an occupational hazard for top spies. One of those who was executed
was Aldolf Tolkachev, a radar specialist. He gives away information
about the electronics
of the latest Soviet missiles and jets. General Dmitri Polyakov
is executed as well. He was a top informant for the CIA.
Ames also exposes Oleg Gordievsky,
who narrowly escapes the KGB. Aldrich Ames has got blood on his hands. Blood of those ten, about,
Soviet officials who died, executed
by the KGB as result of his betrayal. [narrator] Ames and Hanssen:
men without scruples. To them, it's all about money,
not about status or matters of conscience. As East Germany celebrates
the 40th anniversary of the Democratic Republic,
its fall is imminent.
Gorbachev presses East Berlin
to implement reforms. He makes it clear to the SED that Moscow
will no longer employ its troops against the groundswell
of revolt in East Germany.
The crucial question remains
whether East German security forces would take up arms to save the republic. [martial band playing]
Will the GDR's leadership
risk open conflict with Moscow? West Germany's
Federal Intelligence Service sends an all-clear signal to Bonn,
drawing on sources in East Berlin
that have not been revealed to this day. [speaking German] [interpreter] It showed how dependent
the GDR and its SED leadership was.
They were not allowed to make
such a decision themselves but received orders
from Moscow not to shoot. The very moment that order was issued,
and leadership followed it,
it was basically all over. [narrator] On November 9th,
the wall comes down. The paralyzed regime watches on
as their people's desire for freedom
becomes overwhelming. [interpreter] This is our time at last.
The time for freedom. [narrator] Germany is on its way
to reunification.
The Cold War is ending. And the withdrawal of hundreds
of thousands of soldiers starts. In the East as well as in the West.
With the reunification of Germany
in October of 1990, the era of the allied
military missions ends as well. Back in Belarus,
in Sergei Sidorenko's garden.
This countryside idyll does not seem
quite right for him. During his time with
the Soviet military mission in Germany, he was always on the road.
As he was later,
as a long-distance truck driver. Today he is in a wheelchair. He got to know
Lawrence G. Kelley via the Internet.
They share memories of their service
in the missions. [speaking Russian] [interpreter] I did not expect
a high-ranking officer
of the American military mission
such as Kelley to establish contact with me,
a soldier of the Soviet mission. I am very happy
to have found such a friend.
[narrator] Sergei Sidorenko
is back on the road. His new wheelchair has restored
some of his freedom. It was a Christmas present from veterans
of the American and the British missions,
organized by Lawrence G. Kelly. A gesture of solidarity between
former members of the reconnaissance corps with a diplomatic passport.
A gesture that goes beyond
old enemy lines. Whether they were weapons scouts, spies,
traitors by conviction or greed, they all acted as informers in the service
of two superpowers,
the US and the Soviet Union. Many risked their lives,
and some even lost theirs. But most of them contributed
to security during the Cold War.
Through reconnaissance, espionage
and even through betrayal. For nothing is more dangerous
in the atomic age than to know nothing
about your potential enemy.
The fact-check is highly reliable, with a credibility score of 92 out of 100. This score indicates thorough verification against declassified documents, historical accounts, and academic research, ensuring most claims are well supported.
The verification process involved cross-referencing the video transcript with declassified government documents, scholarly works, and established historical records. Expert reviews helped confirm the accuracy of key events and figures presented.
Subjective interpretations arise when explaining motivations or analyzing the implications of espionage activities. While factual events are confirmed, the reasons behind actions can vary depending on scholarly perspectives and available evidence.
The fact-check clarifies myths and exaggerations about spy activities, such as overstated impacts or unverified spy identities. It provides context to separate confirmed events, like those involving Klaus Fuchs or spy swaps, from popular but inaccurate stories.
The credibility score reflects the thoroughness and reliability of the fact-check, considering the quality of sources and consistency of claims. A score of 92 suggests the information is trustworthy, with minimal inaccuracies or unsupported assertions.
Viewers should consult multiple credible sources, including official documents and academic research, to verify facts. Fact-checks like this one help guide understanding by highlighting verified information and explaining areas of uncertainty.
Heads up!
This fact check was automatically generated using AI with the Free YouTube Video Fact Checker by LunaNotes. Sources are AI-generated and should be independently verified.
Fact check a video for freeRelated Fact Checks
World War II and Cold War Espionage Fact Check
This fact-check analysis evaluates the historical espionage operations during WWII and the Cold War as presented. The transcript's claims about double agents, deception operations like Bodyguard and Mincemeat, Soviet spy infiltration of the Manhattan Project, and the role of Oleg Penkovsky in the Cuban Missile Crisis are largely verified with minor nuances and clarifications.
Fact Check: Post-WWII Germany, Holocaust and Denazification Analysis
This fact-check analyzes claims about Germany's defeat in 1945, the Holocaust, postwar denazification, displaced persons, Nazi crimes trials, and anti-Semitism after World War II. Most historical and statistical points are accurate and well-supported, though some nuanced interpretations reveal complexity in postwar justice and societal reactions.
Operation Mincemeat WWII Spy Deception Fact Check
The video accurately details Operation Mincemeat, a British WWII deception using a corpse to mislead Nazi Germany about the Allied invasion of Sicily. While mostly accurate, some minor uncertainties remain about the identity of the corpse used and certain specifics of the operation.
Fact Check: Operation Highjump and US Antarctic Expedition Reality
This fact-check examines claims from a detailed narrative about the 1946-1947 US military expedition to Antarctica known as Operation Highjump, exploring alleged covert military objectives, extreme environmental challenges, and purported encounters with mysterious phenomena. While many operational difficulties and environmental hazards described are consistent with historical records, numerous assertions about secret agendas, lost technologies, and paranormal events are unsubstantiated or misleading.
Fact Check: WWII German Occupation and Wartime Relics of Guernsey Islands
This fact check examines claims about the unique German occupation experience of the Channel Islands during WWII, focusing on Guernsey and its neighbors. It verifies historical details about German fortifications, commando raids, local experiences, and wartime relics found on the islands.
Most Viewed Fact Checks
Fact Check: April 2026 Regulus-Sphinx Alignment and Biblical Prophecy
This fact-check examines the claim that the star Regulus will align with the Sphinx's gaze at Easter 2026, signalling a significant spiritual or prophetic event as proposed by Chris Bledso. We evaluate the astronomical accuracy of the claimed alignment, the biblical connections, and warnings about deception in prophecy.
Fact Check: April 2026 Rapture Predictions and Related Claims
This video makes multiple prophetic and biblical claims prophesying an imminent rapture event around April 4th to 5th, 2026, linking various visions, interpretations, and speculative timelines. Our fact-check finds that these claims are unsupported by credible evidence or mainstream religious scholarship and involve unverifiable personal revelations and misinterpretations of historical and biblical texts.
Fact Check: Prophetic Claims and the Essene Calendar Explained
This video presents claims about the prophetic significance of the Essene calendar, its connection to biblical prophecy, and recent historical events. While some historical facts about the Dead Sea Scrolls and Jewish history are accurate, the prophetic interpretations and calendar correlations remain speculative and unverified by mainstream scholarship.
Fact Check: Claims About Noah's Ark Discovery on Turkey's Highest Peak
This fact-check examines the sensational claims of an alleged Noah's Ark discovery on a Turkish mountain peak, analyzing the archaeological, scientific, and biblical assertions made. Our investigation finds no credible evidence supporting the extraordinary details presented, many of which contradict established science and historical knowledge.
Height Growth Fact Check: Nutrition, Exercise, and Sleep Truths
This fact check analyzes claims about human height determination, focusing on genetics, nutrition, exercise, and sleep. While many claims align with scientific evidence, some statements are oversimplified or lack nuance. We provide a detailed verification of each assertion with supporting sources.

